Bethany, My first Catcher memories are inevitably bound up in a kind of adolescent longing for New York in the sixties. I particularly remember the red cap, wondering what a catcher's mit was and marvelling at how a teenager could be allowed to ride trains by himself. Hmmm, now that I read this list everything sounds like a sexual allusion. Lesley >---------- >From: WILL HOCHMAN[SMTP:hochman@uscolo.edu] >Sent: Monday, 24 November 1997 9:58 >To: bananafish@lists.nyu.edu >Subject: Re: First Catcher memories? > >Dear Bethany, how eloquently you pose the dilemma of reading Catcher as an >adolescent or as an adult. I'm very interested in listening to adults >responding to Catcher and have found that they are much less likely to be >carried away with Holden as younger readers often are...but I am teaching >Catcher in my english class and have to admit that my own reading >continues to understand and love Holden...his confusion is life affirming, >plus I have to admit that I've always interpreted Catcher as a book with a >happy ending since I believe it's writing is the sign that Holden will >make his transition to adulthood as an author. Will > >